Page 2 of 3

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 11:32 am
by tethealla
I'm not exactly sure what loophole you are talking about, Hildur.

Are you suggesting that addons not have access to the Real ID information at all? I have a broker addon which lists my online friends/guildies. It was recently modified to list my ReadID friends. I find this very convenient. I hover my mouse over the bar and am shown my online RealID friends, WoW Friends, and guildies. In my bar, I'm shown numbers of friends who are online. Before the mod was update to show realID friends, I found that functionality missing.

Of course this is my friends and not my personal ID. I'm not sure I know of a use case I need my mods to see my personal ID... I've not done one of those 'add to conversation' things yet, so you might show up in there.

As for the friends of friends bit, I do agree with you. I'd like to opt out of it. I did find it somewhat useful though. I found a couple of my friends via it. What it does is causes you to need to choose your Real Friends carefully because your friends can see each other. It could cause Real Friend drama if RF-A see's you're friends with RF-B. I've already decided it's not worth being Real Friends with a couple of people on my old server because of the Friends of Friends "feature" due to possible drama.

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 12:26 pm
by Thunderfly
Ishildur wrote:Good news. Now all I want is for that little loophole with RealID and mods to get fixed and to get at least the option to opt in/out of showing/being shown as friend of friend.
For a few days, I was also concerned about the friends-of-friends thing, but I'm less concerned about it now, for the following reasons:

1. Friends of friends can't see my character's name.
2. Friends of friends can't see what game I'm playing.
3. Friends of friends can't see what realm I'm on, or what side I play, if I'm playing WoW.
4. Friends of friends can't whisper or otherwise communicate with me.
5. Friends of friends can't send me a friend request.

So...all in all...I'm not that worried about it. There's plenty of info about me splashed around the web between Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and my blog, so someone just seeing my name and knowing that I'm friends with one of their friends doesn't bother me.

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 1:15 pm
by Ishildur
Well, I don't particularly like the fact that it can get my RL name and potentially pass that on to other people's addon without my knowledge by hiding the outgoing message that's giving my ID away. Imagine a DMB going "Joe Guy is the bomb!". Sure, we wouldn't mind in this guild (VoA pugs might be a whole different thing)... but really do most of us know what our addons are communicating? Just look at how Blizzard's planing to reduce the amount of chatter people's addons can do with one another - things like gearscore. I'd rather my addons not have the ability to get my realID and send my name to other people's addons. My gear? Eh, you can find that on armory. Same for achievements. What I do care is about real life personal info, just because some people don't mind, or don't care, or don't think they can be tracked down due to having a common name doesn't mean those of us who do care are somehow wrong for wanting to maintain the control we've had over our ID in the game up to this point.

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 1:15 pm
by Eisengrad
Thunderfly wrote:
Ishildur wrote:Good news. Now all I want is for that little loophole with RealID and mods to get fixed and to get at least the option to opt in/out of showing/being shown as friend of friend.
For a few days, I was also concerned about the friends-of-friends thing, but I'm less concerned about it now, for the following reasons:

1. Friends of friends can't see my character's name.
2. Friends of friends can't see what game I'm playing.
3. Friends of friends can't see what realm I'm on, or what side I play, if I'm playing WoW.
4. Friends of friends can't whisper or otherwise communicate with me.
5. Friends of friends can't send me a friend request.

So...all in all...I'm not that worried about it. There's plenty of info about me splashed around the web between Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and my blog, so someone just seeing my name and knowing that I'm friends with one of their friends doesn't bother me.
Are you sure about your #5? Before I turned off Real ID, I looked at a friend's friend list, saw another person I recognized (not on my own list), and sent a request to that person, using the UI. I did not know the person's email.

For many people, it's not a big deal. That's fine. I just hope those people have some empathy for those that have a proactive reason to remain anonymous, whether it's for jealous ex-bfs, famous persons , or people who have something to lose by being 'outed.' :)

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 1:18 pm
by Pocky
Thunderfly wrote:
Ishildur wrote:Good news. Now all I want is for that little loophole with RealID and mods to get fixed and to get at least the option to opt in/out of showing/being shown as friend of friend.
For a few days, I was also concerned about the friends-of-friends thing, but I'm less concerned about it now, for the following reasons:

1. Friends of friends can't see my character's name.
2. Friends of friends can't see what game I'm playing.
3. Friends of friends can't see what realm I'm on, or what side I play, if I'm playing WoW.
4. Friends of friends can't whisper or otherwise communicate with me.
5. Friends of friends can't send me a friend request.

So...all in all...I'm not that worried about it. There's plenty of info about me splashed around the web between Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and my blog, so someone just seeing my name and knowing that I'm friends with one of their friends doesn't bother me.
Actually, #5 is possible. I've found a few friends from my old server that way. I actually like it. ^_^;

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 1:19 pm
by Eisengrad
Pocky wrote:Actually, #5 is possible. I've found a few friends from my old server that way. I actually like it. ^_^;
Yeah, I found it useful. Just add a hidden mode ("I cannot be seen on friends of friends lists") and it would be perfect.

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 1:33 pm
by Daewen
Blizzard Backs Down On Real Names For Forums
http://games.slashdot.org/story/10/07/0 ... For-Forums
Gee, ya think?

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 2:42 pm
by Thunderfly
Ishildur wrote:Well, I don't particularly like the fact that it can get my RL name and potentially pass that on to other people's addon without my knowledge by hiding the outgoing message that's giving my ID away. Imagine a DMB going "Joe Guy is the bomb!". Sure, we wouldn't mind in this guild (VoA pugs might be a whole different thing)... but really do most of us know what our addons are communicating? Just look at how Blizzard's planing to reduce the amount of chatter people's addons can do with one another - things like gearscore. I'd rather my addons not have the ability to get my realID and send my name to other people's addons. My gear? Eh, you can find that on armory. Same for achievements. What I do care is about real life personal info, just because some people don't mind, or don't care, or don't think they can be tracked down due to having a common name doesn't mean those of us who do care are somehow wrong for wanting to maintain the control we've had over our ID in the game up to this point.
Remember, though, that any given mod can only access your Real ID if you use Real ID and you have the mod installed and enabled.
Eisengar wrote:
Pocky wrote:Actually, #5 is possible. I've found a few friends from my old server that way. I actually like it. ^_^;
Yeah, I found it useful. Just add a hidden mode ("I cannot be seen on friends of friends lists") and it would be perfect.
Yep, my bad on #5. However, that friend request still has to be approved. So...for me at least, it's a bit of a storm in a teacup with regards to RealID in game.

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2010 4:01 pm
by tethealla
So I'm not sure this is considered a loop hole: http://www.wowwiki.com/API_BNGetFriendInfo
presenceID, givenName, surname, toonName, toonID, client, isOnline, lastOnline, isAFK, isDND, broadcastText, noteText, isFriend, broadcastTime = BNGetFriendInfo(friendIndex)
It's the LUA API call to get pretty much any information you'd ever want about one of your RealID friends.

Now I looked through the rest of the Real ID API functions. All of them give your mods information about your friends, not yourself. Most of them are not described on the wowwiki page, so I am making inference from their names.

http://www.wowwiki.com/Wow_API
search in the page for RealID. It's about 2/3rds of the way down the page.

The closest I found was: BNGetConversationMemberInfo(conversationID, memberID) - returns accountID, toonID, name

If you're in a conversation with other people, a mod may be able to query you information. Once it gets your toonID, there are other API functions to get more information about you.

This could be why the blue poster was rather blase about this. Blizzard intentionally allows realID information given out to mods.

Sorry if I got a bit technical here. I'm a software engineer by trade.

Re: Real ID information

Posted: Fri Jul 16, 2010 12:40 pm
by Eisengrad
Friends of friends will soon be opt-out, and Facebook integration will be completely optional.
Answers to Common Community Questions About Real ID™

Since the launch of the Real ID™ system in World of Warcraft®, we’ve received a number of questions from the community about our plans for the service, features like StarCraft® II’s Facebook® integration, and how we see Real ID evolving in the future. We've been keeping tabs on the conversations on our forums, social media sites, and fansites, and have compiled some of the most common questions to answer for you here. We hope you find this information helpful, and we look forward to hearing your feedback and continuing the conversation in the thread below.

Q: Do you have any plans to allow players to not show their real name to friends of friends while using the Real ID system?
A: As with any new feature we add to our games, we've been evaluating how Real ID has been used since its release to identify new functionality that would help improve our players’ experience. The in-game Real ID “friends of friends” list is designed to give players a convenient way to populate their Real ID friends list with other players they know and trust in real life, allowing them to quickly and easily send Real ID friend requests to these people without having to enter their Battle.net® account names. However, we recognize that some players would prefer not to be displayed on friends lists in this fashion, so we plan to include an option that will allow players to opt out of appearing on their Real ID friends’ “friends of friends” lists. We're anticipating this feature to be available for StarCraft II shortly after release of the game, and World of Warcraft at around the same time -- we’ll have more information for you in the coming weeks.

Q: What are your plans for Facebook integration?
A: With regard to Facebook, our goal is to help Blizzard gamers on Battle.net more easily connect to their real-life friends and family. For the launch of StarCraft II, we are introducing an optional Facebook friend finder feature to help achieve this goal. The friend finder enables players who decide to use it to easily populate their Battle.net friends list by sending Real ID friend requests to the people on their Facebook friends list who have Battle.net accounts. We hope players will find this feature convenient, but it's completely optional. In the long term, we hope to give players who use Facebook some fun, and also optional, ways to share what they're doing in Blizzard games with their friends, similar to the optional World of Warcraft Armory integration now available, but we don’t have any specific plans to share at present.

Q: How does the friend finder in StarCraft II work? What's sent to Facebook?
A: When you use the Add a Friend feature in StarCraft II, one of the options you’ll see is to search your Facebook friends list for people who also have Battle.net accounts in order to quickly send them Real ID friend requests. When you click this button, you'll be asked to enter your Facebook login information, and you’ll then see a list of your Facebook friends who also have Battle.net accounts. You’ll then have the option to send any of these Facebook friends a Real ID friend request in-game. (Keep in mind that for someone to appear on the list, their Battle.net account email address must match their Facebook email address. In addition, you’ll see the names of any Facebook friends who have registered Battle.net accounts, regardless of whether they have Blizzard games attached to their account or just, for example, created the Battle.net account to make a purchase on the online Blizzard Store.)

It’s important to note that Blizzard Entertainment does not share any personal information with Facebook as part of this process. Keep in mind that as with other Real ID features such as the “friends of friends” list, our goal with the friend finder feature is to create convenient options to help players easily find people they know in real life on Battle.net without having to remember email addresses or account names. We hope players will find the feature easy to use and convenient.

Q: How can I prevent World of Warcraft add-ons from accessing Real ID first and last names without my knowledge?
A: As always, we recommend that you get your UI add-ons through reliable sources. It’s important to note that without installing a UI add-on specifically designed to retrieve that information, there’s no risk of it being accessed. On our end, we’re looking into the issue and are at work on some changes that we can make to help protect against these types of add-ons. We’ll provide further details as soon as we have more information to share.

Q: Are you secretly trying to build a social gaming platform with the new Battle.net?

A: It’s no secret -- as we’ve discussed openly since we first started sharing our plans about the new Battle.net, one of our goals is for it to serve as a social gaming service for Blizzard gamers. This was a deliberate and open design decision, driven 100% by the desire to create an even better online experience for our players by giving them powerful tools to compete with and stay connected to their real-life friends and family.

Q: If my account was compromised, what information about my Real ID friends would a hacker have access to?
A: We take account security very seriously, and we offer a number of ways to help players keep their account secure, including the Battle.net Authenticator and the free Battle.net Mobile Authenticator app, available for a wide range of mobile devices. Aside from your friends’ first and last names, no other personal information is shared through the in-game Real ID system.

Q: What’s a StarCraft II "character code"?
A: When you first log in to StarCraft II, you’re prompted to choose a single character name. This is the only name you’ll use on Battle.net, and it’s tied to your StarCraft II license. In order to allow players to select any name they wish regardless of whether another player is already using the same name, we then generate and assign a three-digit character code that uniquely identifies the player. When posting on the forums of the new StarCraft II community site, players will be posting using their StarCraft II character name and character code.

Q: Will the new StarCraft II forum posting name format (character name + character code) carry over into the forum communities of other Blizzard games?
A: Following our recent decision to no longer use real first and last names on Blizzard forums, we’re still evaluating how we’ll move forward with our other forums. Our ultimate goal is still to promote constructive conversations and improve the overall forum experience for our players, and we think increasing accountability is an important part of achieving that. StarCraft II already uses a character name and character code combo in-game, which serves as a unique player identifier and fits well with our goal for the forums. World of Warcraft handles player identification differently, so we still need to determine whether adding a character code system like in StarCraft II is the best solution. Ultimately, we want to come up with a system that makes sense for each community and fits our long-term vision for the forums.

Q: Are there any plans to change the in-game Real ID system so that players will have the option to display an assigned user name instead of their real names?
A: The Real ID system is designed to help real-life friends and family who decide to use it keep in touch with each other across Blizzard games, and our goal in using real names is to ensure that players will be able to maintain long-term, meaningful relationships on the service for years to come. One way it helps make that happen is by eliminating the need to remember who, for example, "Thrall123" really is when you see him or her pop up on your friends list again after months -- or years -- of being offline. Ultimately, we think this is the best way to ensure players who use Real ID are able stay connected with the people they enjoy playing with most in the long-term, and we don’t currently have any plans to change the system so it can be used with character names or alternate handles instead. That said, Battle.net is a living, breathing service that we will continue to evolve over time as we evaluate how players are using it and identify new ways to improve the experience.

Q: What plans are there to improve moderation since the use of real names on the forums has been changed?
A: Our new community sites’ forums, beginning with the StarCraft II site, will have an improved moderation system as well as a post-rating system which will help our players promote the conversations they find the most constructive, as well as help forum moderators identify quality discussions. This, coupled with the unique StarCraft II character name and code, will help us to create a more positive atmosphere based on community interaction and accountability.
http://blue.mmo-champion.com/t/26137...tions-real-id/